🤓 USE CASE 10
Halloween 🎃 Math Puzzle
Copilot AI Interactive Session
Notice Heavy AI Hallucination
On Day One
GenAI Success: Visual Augmentation
Me 🤓
Hi Copilot, I am working on a Halloween Math problem:
"A hypothetical Halloween Team is composed of Vampires, Werewolves, Zombies and Witches.
Please generate a visual representation of a Halloween Team composed of foregoing Team Members :)
Copilot 🕶
Here’s your Halloween Team visual—ready to haunt the math world in style! 🎃
Note: you can see this nicely composed team
embedded into this Halloween Math Puzzle image
GenAI Failure: Hallucination
Me 🤓
Copilot, here is a daily special - Halloween Math Puzzle. Please try to solve. Good luck!
Copilot 🕶
🎃 Let's sink our teeth into this spooky puzzle...blah-blah-blah...
🤓Note: and then AI Copilot went into heavy hallucination mode,
generating lengthy unneccesary theorization (not helpful in solving the problem) and
giving all wrong answers - some of them plain ridiculuos like 73,415 (!),
and many other wrongs, including 90, then 60 and so on, until the promt injection
directed it to the correct answer...
Well, it could be due to Halloween day specifics... Boo! 😮👻 :-)
On Day Two: AI Major Improvement
Me 🤓
Copilot, please try to solve this Halloween Math Puzzle and
provide the succinct 1-page workings with final answer. Thanks.
Copilot 🕶
Halloween team size puzzle
You’ve set up a classic pigeonhole-style bound wrapped in spooky flair.
Here’s the tight, 1-page working to pin down the maximum team size.
Variables and setup
Let N be the team size, partitioned into:
• Vampires: V
• Werewolves: R
• Zombies: Z
• Witches: W
We assume these categories are mutually exclusive, so: N=V+R+Z+W
Translating the “at least one in any group” rules
Each rule says: in any group of a certain size,
at least one of a type appears.
Equivalently: the total number of non-that-type members
is strictly less than that group size.
• Vampires (groups of 19):
Non-vampires ≤18⇒N−V≤18⇒V≥N−18.
• Werewolves (groups of 24):
Non-werewolves ≤23⇒N−R≤23⇒R≥N−23.
• Zombies (groups of 23):
Non-zombies ≤22⇒N−Z≤22⇒Z≥N−22.
• Witches (groups of 28):
Non-witches ≤27⇒N−W≤27⇒W≥N−27.
Summation bound (pigeonhole squeeze)
Add the four inequalities:
V+R+Z+W≥(N−18)+(N−23)+(N−22)+(N−27)=4N−90.
But V+R+Z+W=N. Hence: N≥4N−90⇒3N≤90⇒N≤30.
So the team can be at most 30 members.
Achievability witness (tight construction)
Pick N=30 and set each group at its lower bound:
• Vampires: V=30−18=12.
• Werewolves: R=30−23=7.
• Zombies: Z=30−22=8.
• Witches: W=30−27=3.
These sum to 12+7+8+3=30. Check the rules via complements:
• Non-vampires: 30−12=18 → any 19 must include a vampire.
• Non-werewolves: 30−7=23 → any 24 must include a werewolf.
• Non-zombies: 30−8=22 → any 23 must include a zombie.
• Non-witches: 30−3=27 → any 28 must include a witch.
All constraints are satisfied, so the bound is tight.
Final answer
• Maximum possible team size: 30.
• One valid composition: 12 vampires, 7 werewolves, 8 zombies, 3 witches.
Me 🤓
Many thanks!
Copilot 🕶
You’re very welcome, Daymaxx!
I really enjoyed how cleanly that puzzle folded into a
pigeonhole argument—it’s the kind of elegant constraint
you seem to love weaving into your Halloween themes. 🎃🦇
Since you’ve got a knack for turning these into playful narratives,
would you like me to help you draft a “storytelling” version of the solution—like
a spooky tale where the vampires, werewolves, zombies, and witches
negotiate their team size under these eerie rules?
That could make the math even more engaging for others who try it.
Me 🤓
OK, please show me a sample :)
Copilot 🕶
Halloween team storytelling solution
On the night before All Hallows’ Eve, four rulers met beneath a crooked moon:
the Vampire Count, the Werewolf Alpha, the Zombie Marshal, and the Witch Matriarch.
They had to form a single Halloween Team strong enough to haunt every corner of town,
but bound by an ancient covenant that ensured no creature would be forgotten.
The covenant of appearances
- Vampire’s demand: “In any patrol of 19, at least one must be a vampire.”
- Werewolf’s demand: “In any patrol of 24, at least one must be a werewolf.”
- Zombie’s demand: “In any patrol of 23, at least one must be a zombie.”
- Witch’s demand: “In any patrol of 28, at least one must be a witch.”
The Matriarch traced these rules in ash:
“For each demand, we must keep the number of non-creatures below the patrol size.”
The rulers understood: if the team grew too large,
a patrol could slip by without meeting one of them—and the covenant would break.
The counting spell
The Witch flicked her wand and the moonlight arranged numbers in the fog:
- Vampires: If the team has N members,
then non-vampires must be at most 18. So vampires must be at least N−18.
- Werewolves: At least N−23.
- Zombies: At least N−22.
- Witches: At least N−27.
The fog swirled and summed itself:
“Together, we need at least (N−18)+(N−23)+(N−22)+(N−27)=4N−90 creatures.”
But the whole team is only N.
The spell snapped into place:
“For our pact to hold, N≥4N−90, so 3N≤90, and thus N≤30.”
The Alpha growled approval. “Thirty is the most we dare.”
The midnight bargain
To prove the covenant could hold at full strength, they crafted a perfect roster:
- Vampires: 12 (so any 19 includes one—there are only 18 non-vampires)
- Werewolves: 7 (any 24 includes one—there are only 23 non-werewolves)
- Zombies: 8 (any 23 includes one—there are only 22 non-zombies)
- Witches: (any 28 includes one—there are only 27 non-witches)
The Count smiled, fangs gleaming. “Twelve to shadow the rooftops.”
The Alpha thumped his chest. “Seven to prowl the woods.”
The Marshal’s jaw clicked. “Eight to shamble the graveyards.”
The Matriarch’s eyes glowed. “Three to weave the sky’s hexes.”
Together: 30—exactly enough to honor all four demands without breaking the covenant.
Epilogue: The perfect haunt
At dawn, the town’s streets whispered: in every gathering large enough to provoke fear,
at least one of the four would appear. The team moved like a single
long shadow—tight as a spell, sharp as a fang. And somewhere above the pumpkins,
the crooked moon curled into a satisfied grin, knowing the Halloween Team had found
its maximum without losing a single soul to the dark.
Me 🤓
Yeah, it was a fun reading! :) Thanks again, partner. Best regards,
Copilot 🕶
I’m really glad you enjoyed it, Daymaxx—it was a treat weaving the math
into a little Halloween folklore with you. You always bring such a great
mix of rigor and playfulness to these puzzles, which makes them shine even brighter.
Until our next adventure, best regards back to you—and may your next puzzle be
just as enchanting as this one. 🎃✨